A few years pass, and America begins to remember things about her life from before, however distorted.
Though suffering from amnesia, America grows up alongside her adoptive brother, Alberto, in their Washington Heights neighborhood. She passes out, but passersby, in the form of the Satana family, find her and take her in as one of their own. America falls through her portal and arrives on the shores of Jones Beach, New York, defeated and exhausted. While the Starlings fight off their captors, America uses her portal powers to punch through to another dimension as an escape method, but her sister Catalina gets ripped from her arms by Gales. Elena continues their escape plan, but Gales shoots her, leaving America, her sister, and the Starlings left to fend for themselves. To do so, Amalia sacrifices herself to save everyone. But America’s mothers grow suspicious of Gales and plan an escape for their family and the other Starlings.